Home About Us Contact Us IndyScribe Gear Indianapolis All Articles Syndication Feed Comments Feed

Brainard and Seward

Topic: Museums and Visual Arts

Posted: Fri, Dec 14, 2007

Just over two years ago, I wrote some hopped-up bit about Carmel and its corporate built arts district. So obviously this little tid-bit in the news could not have escaped my notice.

Carmel orders 10 more outdoor sculptures Public arts funding to provide nearly $1M for 1 current, 10 new lifelike sculptures

CARMEL, Ind. -- Mayor Jim Brainard has ordered 10 more lifelike sculptures for his outdoor public art display in the Arts & Design District.

He'll use public arts funding to pay for the J. Seward Johnson Jr. pieces, which come with a price tag of about $1 million. That also includes the cost of a statue already in the district.

The Norman Rockwell-style statues depict scenes such as a boy riding on his father's shoulders and a woman walking a dog.

....

Brainard said the statues will attract businesses to the Arts & Design District and enhance the quality of life in Carmel, making it easier to draw corporations to the city.
"It creates economic activity in this area that for many years wasn't doing well," Brainard said.

Some criticize spending taxpayer money on the statues.

"To take away people's tax dollars and spend it on art that usually is funded by private benefactors is just unbelievable," said Mark Rattermann, a city councilman who proposed cutting arts funding from this year's city budget. "The mayor believes that we should spend tax dollars for entertainment and culture. And he calls himself a Republican."

Sue Maki, president of the Hamilton County Tourism Commission, said the statues will be worth the investment because of the tourism they'll bring to Carmel. She said the statues would provide an impetus for people to come to Hamilton County and explore its offerings.

"It just adds to the tourism product we have here," Maki said. "It's a place-making type of action in this city. Ten years from now, we'll be very thankful."

http://www.indystar.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20071214/LOCAL/712140457/1006

It's a bit humorous. $1 million dollars for ten statues.

We often rail against the government for not supporting the arts, but then when a move like this comes along, we shake our fingers in judgment. The line from Councilman Rattermann is a good one. I slightly give Mayor Brainard props for following through with the notion of an arts district, but I still find his methods unsound.

And I'm sure there are more people in Carmel who do as well.

Let's go back to that figure - one million dollars. How extravagant and posh does a city street need to be to spend that kind of money on outdoor art? Wouldn't that money be better put to use by say... improving some roads? How about putting more cash into the schools that sit right down the block? Why not enrich the community and commission a local sculptor (for cheaper most likely)?

Yes, I know, Seward is a recognized name in the art world, and it gives "value" to the district to have such a name attached to it in order to draw... something. Tourists? I suppose. High school art classes across the central Indiana area will be flocking to Carmel now, wishing they had the cash to buy more gallon jugs of tempera paint and fimo clay, being so inspired.

Comments

1. Dec 15, 07 07:17 AM | Norm said:

And yet ... the people keep electing him to office. At some point ... they will be forced to pay for maintaining all the new growth.

2. Jan 9, 08 12:41 PM | Sean said:

The thing is Carmel has the money to spend like this. I mean have you been to the high school? It is immense, i mean, it has a freaking planetarium. Thats right a state of the art planetarium. There's really no homeless in Carmel, they already spend millions on the roads. They just have the kind of money and don't have the problems, to be able to spend like this. I just think it works for this affluent town. Although I personally don't care for the sculptures. I think they're boring.

3. Jan 30, 08 01:57 PM | Michael Packer said:

Actually, yeah, I've been to the high school down the street, as well as the library and the learning center. They're all very nice and probably really don't need much in the way of funds, but that just pokes holes in my liberal fueled outlook. :D

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)





TrackBacks

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.indyscribe.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/434

Captain Jack Glasscock

Archives

IndyScribe Authors

Guest Authors

Powered by Movable Type 3.33
Hosted by LivingDot